Resurface or Replace Concrete - Which One to Pick?

February 23, 2023

Concrete is one of the most commonly used materials in construction, thanks to its durability, strength, and low cost. Yet with time, wear and tear can cause cracks, discoloration, and other damage to concrete surfaces, leading to wear and tear. When this occurs, it's crucial to pick the best concrete repair method, whether that's resurfacing or replacement.

In this blog post, we'll discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each choice as well as the factors to take into account while making the choice.

Reasons for Concrete Repair

Concrete repair is frequently necessary for a number of reasons. The decision between resurfacing and replacement may depend on the severity of the damage. Resurfacing might be a good alternative, for instance, if the damage is minor and only affects the concrete's surface. However, replacement may be required if the damage is more severe and compromises the concrete's structural integrity.

Resurfacing Concrete

Resurfacing is the process of covering an existing surface with a thin layer of concrete. This can be done to fix minor surface damage or to enhance the concrete's look. Resurfacing has many benefits, including speed of completion and cost-effectiveness.

If there is no significant structural damage and the concrete's base is stable, it's also a smart solution. Resurfacing does, however, have some drawbacks, such as the necessity for a solid basis and durability. Resurfacing might not be a possibility if the concrete's base is unstable.

Replacing Concrete

Concrete replacement involves taking out the old concrete and laying new concrete in its place. Compared to resurfacing, this procedure is more complicated and usually takes longer to finish. Yet, a replacement has a number of benefits, including enhanced aesthetics and long-term durability.

Replacement of the concrete might be needed if the damage is severe and compromises its structural integrity. It's crucial to take into account replacement's higher prices and longer completion time frames.

Pros and Cons of Replacing Concrete

Pros of Replacing Concrete:

  • Durability: New concrete offers a strong and durable surface that can last for decades.
  • Aesthetics: Replacing old and worn-out concrete can greatly improve the appearance of your property.
  • Increased Property Value: A new and improved concrete surface can increase the value of your property.
  • Customization: With the option to choose from a variety of colors and designs, you can customize your new concrete surface to your liking.

Cons of Replacing Concrete:

  • Cost: Replacing concrete can be expensive, especially if you have a large area to cover.
  • Time-Consuming: Replacing concrete is a time-consuming process, which may cause inconvenience to you and your family.
  • Disruption: During the replacement process, the area being worked on will be inaccessible, which can disrupt your daily activities.
  • Environmental Impact: Concrete production is a major source of greenhouse gas emissions, so replacing concrete can have negative environmental impacts.

Pros and Cons of Resurfacing Concrete

Pros of Resurfacing Concrete:

  • Cost-Effective: Resurfacing concrete is typically more affordable than replacing it.
  • Quick Process: Resurfacing concrete can usually be completed in just a few days, causing minimal disruption.
  • Improved Appearance: Resurfacing concrete can restore the appearance of an old and worn-out surface, giving it a fresh and new look.
  • Customization: With a range of colors, textures, and designs available, you can customize your resurfaced concrete to suit your preferences.

Cons of Resurfacing Concrete:

  • Durability: Resurfacing concrete may not last as long as replacing it, particularly if the original concrete is severely damaged.
  • Surface Preparation: Resurfacing concrete requires a clean and level surface, which may require additional preparation time and effort.
  • Not Suitable for All Damage: Resurfacing concrete is not suitable for all types of damage, such as deep cracks or structural issues.
  • Limited Thickness: Resurfacing concrete can only be done to a limited thickness, so if the concrete is severely damaged, replacing it may be necessary.

Factors to Consider when Choosing between Resurfacing and Replacement

There are a number of things to take into account while deciding between replacement and resurfacing. Budget, timeline, degree of damage, and the intended use of the concrete surface are a few of these. Resurfacing might be the ideal choice, for instance, if cost is a key consideration.

On the other hand, if durability is very important, you might need to get a replacement. The decision could also be influenced by how the concrete surface will be used. But no matter which option you choose, make sure to hire a reputable contractor who can do good work and make sure your concrete surface will last.

Smith Evergreen Concrete

Give us a call at Smith Evergreen Concrete if you live in Richmond and want to learn more about your concrete repair options.

Related post

The pros and cons of concrete floor

Concrete flooring is a popular choice for homes and businesses because of its durability and low maintenance. However, before making a final decision, it is important to carefully weigh all of the pros and cons. If you are unsure whether concrete flooring is right for you, it is best to consult with a flooring professional […]
Read more

Concrete Floor Maintenance

Concrete floors are a popular choice for many commercial and industrial settings due to their durability and versatility. However, like any other type of flooring, concrete floors require proper maintenance to keep them looking and functioning at their best. Here's everything you need to know about the importance of concrete floor maintenance, as well as […]
Read more

What our clients are saying

  • Sam and the team at Smith Evergreen are absolutely awesome. They did a great job, it turned out fantastic. My neighbors already asked for their info. Thank you!
    Mike Clute
  • My sidewalk is finally even, and our steps are nicely spaced!
  • Widening our walkway made our front yard so much more inviting
Welcome to Smith Evergreen Concrete, Richmond Virginia's newest concrete contractor. While we may new to RVA and working throughout Central Virginia, we're not new concrete.  For the last 6 years we've been dedicated to perfecting our trade while working diligently to study the craft of custom stamped concrete in the North West. We are excited to be in Richmond, with family and friends and to have the opportunity to bring our high-quality concrete craftsmanship to the beautiful state of Virginia. 

Contact Us

Richmond, virginia
(804) 994-8950